So It's Back To First Principles

Beaver ESU Witness 3 is Nicol.
Butler ESU Witness 4 is Murcko
Butler ESU Witness 3 is likely a QRF member near the north barn. I haven’t been able to ID him yet.

I am in the middle of my detailed analysis of that report as it pertains to Nicol and Murcko, but I know that the times Murcko and the QRF witness say they first spot Crooks on AGR property are before he’s even on the property as evidenced by Jon Malis’ dashcam video, which shows him walking onto the property at ~17:04. Nicol’s times align with his previous testimony during the ABC and CNN interviews.

4 Likes

Congratulations on the appeal win. I recently read on X where someone had to appeal a RTK request denial due to Kusak not reading his emails. They won their appeal as well. You are wise to stick with it and not take “no” for an answer. :+1::+1:

5 Likes

Back in mid-September I did a sidebar analysis of the Butler & Beaver County documents to point out their inaccuracies. I included most of that in my timeline analysis of the Door 9 and 13 events, which I’m currently updating to reflect the congressional investigation reports and released radio logs. I first revised my analysis of the AAR timeline entries and maps, and to minimize the size of that analysis I decided to separate that into a sidebar analysis. Here is that analysis. Before using those maps, and the 18:06-18:12 timeline entry for supporting evidence, I highly encourage you to consider my analysis.

Sidebar Analysis - AAR Timeline (Rev 3).pdf (2.5 MB)

5 Likes

Next up is my revision to my timeline analysis of the ESU Armor & Response to include a missed radio log segment and the images below.

https://x.com/Birdy1776/status/1842995994109399148

3 Likes

@redranamber

Do you see what I see from the images posted above? You were right!

image

3 Likes

Hey what do you know, a lighter colored BuC patch!! Nice catch @vegaspatriot !
He’s actually sporting both variations of the patch too, which is neat!
image

These photos are great quality, Josh Drespling got fantastic footage and video! I’m wondering what else he may have captured that day and just not released.

I would say our BuC team here appears to be from CAT1, here’s a few quick comparisons, not confirmed certainly though I’m guessing here we have Fleming, Schaffner, Soler (medic), and Mikulan (in his trademark neck gaiter/mask!):

Oh, while we’re at it, did we ever figure out who this grey suit gentleman is, or have any ideas? Perhaps, what was it, Burr or something like that?

Also, I’ve made some progress on the Kuss cam captioning, still not complete but much closer:

3 Likes

Mikulan went with USSS in the motorcade, so I think that is Niederlander since Oesterling was still being looked for. (Edit: will be looked for ~6 minutes later.)

I also think 2 patch guy is May. Compare him to his 2019 photo and add a few pounds and 5 years. Schaffner is probably the one in the upper left behind gray suit Trump campaign guy, who I haven’t tried to ID. We can read Soler’s nametag on his back, and I agree with you on Fleming.

Nice job on Kuss’ radio comms/bodycam.

2 Likes

This is from the radio log segment I was missing. This is after the Dutch treatment scene photos, and Schaffner lists who he will have.

image

image

1 Like

:sweat_smile: Dickey? And now a mystery Dickey pops up? Eeesh, I wonder if this is just a nickname for someone we’ve already got or if this indicates present members not included in the reports.

And thank you, that is quite a useful series of transmissions indeed! Funny I was right around that spot with my Kuss cam project and completely overlooked those as I was hunting for PDOps3! Had my damn blinders on! :laughing:

1 Like

Think I’ve found our Dickey! Derek Dickey, Slippery Rock.


Police Dept

2 Likes

I just saw this Ken Silva post showing portions of the radio calls with protected comments WHILE SHOTS ARE BEING FIRED!

https://x.com/JD_Cashless/status/1851840744463499538

I would like to get a copy of that version, which I think he posted on Scribd but a few days ago that file was stated as having been removed.

2 Likes

Bingo! Good work.

1 Like

That’s quite interesting, this as yet unidentified radio id making calls in that timeframe on PDOps4. It is quite difficult to determine much more than that from this photo, but I see what you mean with the protected notes, though all these entries have no note associated, I would be curious to see what of the rest of the log.

3 Likes

Here is where the link to SCRIBD goes from the associated Headline USA article. I think it was the full spreadsheet of the unofficial version, though, the one we have with slightly crooked tables.

1 Like

Hello. I believe this link should work.

3 Likes

Got it! Thank you so much. I should know better…“ask and you shall receive.”

2 Likes

Of course! We can thank Ken Silva & Evan Coons. Evan asked for the link and Ken provided it. I just copied and pasted.

Evan Coons on X has put a lot of time into the metadata. You would find what he has put together helpful, I’m sure.

3 Likes

Yes, I’m running across more of his posts the more I search various X accounts. I don’t get much time to do that with all of the slide decks I’m trying to keep current and the various analyses I have in progress, so I try to do it on breaks. But sometimes, like today, Divine intervention leads me to evidence that fit’s exactly what I’m working on, which never ceases to amaze me. For example, I’m revising my ESU Armor & Response analysis for the missing timeline segment, and I am lead to discover those John Drespling photos that not only fit right in with that timeline, it provides field images for the Recognition Tools we previously did not have for CAT #1.

2 Likes

Found a lead on our missing radio id, 60726! Now I know I saw on Pearson’s cam footage he used the mic in his car, perhaps that has something to do with his alternate radio ids? Or perhaps he was running multiple radios?


Edit: just realized my mistake in PDOps3 and 4…

2 Likes

I’ll be damned. After posting my last reply to you I went back to @Birdy1776’s X account and scrolled down just one more post and look what I find. Never, ever ceases to amaze me!

2 Likes