Fuzzier than ever - GDP reported to be 3.3%

A truly laughably fraudulent GDP report was released by the government today. However, we're getting close to this just being a sad parody of Soviet crop reports of old, which were famous for being utterly out of alignment with reality.

3.3% GDP Growth Stronger Than Expected
(August 28 -New York Times)


The economy expanded faster from April to June than originally thought, the government said on Thursday, catching many economists off-guard and cheering investors on Wall Street.

Gross domestic product rose at a 3.3 percent clip in the second quarter, the Commerce Department said, a significant jump over the original estimate of 1.9 percent growth. G.D.P., the broadest measure of the nation’s economic activity, is considered a good barometer of America’s economic health.

The revised G.D.P. figure suggests resilience in the economy, especially compared with the anemic 0.9 percent growth rate from January to March, and a contraction in the final three months of 2007. Still, spending by American consumers stayed relatively soft, despite the infusion of the government’s tax stimulus program. Corporate profits remained weak.


Shame on the New York Times for printing propaganda and then charging for it. That should be free.

When this report of 3.3% growth for the second quarter came out, I laughed out loud. That is how preposterous it was. Besides this completely rigged report by the government, almost every other, non-fudgeable number is in agreement; we are in a deep recession.Cars, houses, retail, job claims, the ECRI, you name it - they all say "recession".


How did they arrive at this very funny 3.3% reading? Two ways.


First, they had to concoct a massive upward revision to exports.


Next, they did something that shocked even me; they knocked inflation for the second quarter of 2008 to only 1.3%, the second lowest reading in of the past 15 quarters.

That is, the claim they are making here is that inflation for April, May, and June was down, and down a lot. Here’s the picture:



See that yellow circle? That’s the amount of inflation that was subtracted for the nominal GDP reading to derive the so-called “real” GDP that was just reported. Today that term “real” took on new, ironic overtones. Let’s review a few of the things that actually happened during April, May, and June. Here’s the CPI for that period:

Even as badly mangled as the CPI data is, it averaged 4.38% for those three months – a full 329% HIGHER than the number used to calculate the GDP.

Gas prices hit a record, oil prices hit a record, food inflation edged close to double digits, and yet, through all of this, the US government puts out an completely preposterous number of only 1.3%, utterly secure in the knowledge that nobody, not even the New York Times, would ask so much as a single uncomfortable question about whether or not this is a believable number. In fact, the NYT did the opposite, by immediately pointing out that this surprisingly strong GDP reading suggests 'resiliency' in the economy.

And Wall Street rallied hard on this news today, just as they were supposed to. However, anybody who bought stocks on this news was defrauded and will almost certainly regret the decision.

This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://peakprosperity.com/fuzzier-than-ever-gdp-reported-to-be-3-3-2/