Paper Markets That Mislead Will Eventually Fail

Originally published at: https://peakprosperity.com/paper-markets-that-mislead-will-eventually-fail/

In this episode of Finance U, Paul Kiker and I discuss the recent gold and silver smackdown, the looming copper shortages, European economic thrashings about, and how Private Equity and the Subprime debt bankruptcies may be indicating that things are breaking down “from the outside in.”

As you probably know, gold and silver have been vaulting to new highs for weeks, seemingly without any down days. While due for a correction, or at least a consolidation, the way they both tumbled in the dead of night was highly suspicious, to say the least.

For example, silver saw an absolutely massive 42,320,000 ounce dump in a single 15-minute window at 4 in the morning

It was the same for gold.

This is typical bullion bank paper shenanigans, a routine I’ve seen play out dozens of times over my career as an astute and diligent watcher of their gold and silver antics.

But we speculated that perhaps this time there was a whiff of true desperation in the air. A last gasp attempt to regain some level of pricing power and control. But, as is typical of the amoral and immoral financial engineers of London and Wall Street, they did not attempt to do this honestly by accumulating or selling actual gold or silver, but dishonestly by dumping unlimited quantities of paper gold and silver derivatives, a.k.a. “futures.”

The problem? Those futures come with an obligation to deliver if the counterparty ‘stands for delivery.’ That delivery month is December 2025, so we’ll be watching that very closely to see if these recent paper shenanigans backfire on the bullion banks or not. I’m leaning towards ‘yes’ on that front…but they’ve been pretty good at avoiding that outcome for decades so it’s not a sure thing.

One clue as to the predicament of the Bullion banks, such as JP Morgan, is that even as they are busy driving down the price of silver with their blizzards of paper contracts, creating the appearance that silver is unwanted and in abundant supply, they are quietly telling their largest customers that there’s none that can be delivered “until November.”

Which is it? Are there 42 million ounces suddenly available at 4 in the morning, or none that can be actually sourced until November?

Also of note, we discussed this potential bombshell where India’s banks and financial system can now issue loans against physical gold and silver held as collateral, which effectively (re)monetizes both metals:

(Source)

With silver now operating as money in India, at least partly, this places yet one more source of demand on a perilously stretched silver supply chain that is already running large and persistent supply deficits.

So, yeah, I consider the paper dumps to be last-ditch efforts to clear out as many weak hands as possible before the jig is up.

Speaking of which, the same dynamics of paper contracts dominating and distorting markets can be seen all across the entire commodity complex. One of the consistent features of a commodity that is dominated by futures contracts is that the price for the commodity always remains ridiculously low, for far too long, and eventually you end up with a situation where a rather severe shortage finally emerges.

Copper tells that tale as well as any other commodity. Note that total copper discoveries totaled just 11 between 2013 and 2023:

As we can see in the above graphic, discoveries really fell off a cliff right around 2008. Looking at the futures dominated price for copper, it’s price rose in the vicinity of 25% between 2008 and 2023…but collapsed by 50% between 2008 and 2016, from $4/lb to just $2/lb.

Was $2/lb the ‘right’ price for copper in 2016? I don’t think so, and the evidence is in the absolute paucity of interest in discovering and bringing on line new copper mines, which is going to be a huge problem in the not-too-distant future.

As for Europe, Germany is a very sick country having followed the WEF/Brussels green energy playbook to its bitter end. Rapidly deindustrializing, all Germany’s leaders can think to do is more of the same things that got them into this mess in the first place.

Martin Armstrong sees this clearly and warns Europeans that they have a limited time to move capital out of Europe and out of the rapidly approaching digital; CBDC system that has just been rolled out:

(Source)

Taken together, the above suggests that having a risk-managed portfolio strategy is more important than ever, as is having a financial advisor who sees these larger risks the same way that you do. To schedule your free, no obligation portfolio review and wealth strategy session with Kiker Wealth Management, just click this link, fill out the simple form, and someone from KWM will get in touch with you within 48 business hours to schedule your session(s).


FINANCIAL DISCLAIMER. PEAK PROSPERITY, LLC, AND PEAK FINANCIAL INVESTING ARE NOT ENGAGED IN RENDERING LEGAL, TAX, OR FINANCIAL ADVICE OR SERVICES VIA THIS WEBSITE. NEITHER PEAK PROSPERITY, LLC NOR PEAK FINANCIAL INVESTING ARE FINANCIAL PLANNERS, BROKERS, OR TAX ADVISORS. Their websites are intended only to assist you in your financial education. Your personal financial situation is unique, and any information and advice obtained through this website may not be appropriate for your situation. Accordingly, before making any final decisions or implementing any financial strategy, you should consider obtaining additional information and advice from your accountant or other financial advisers who are fully aware of your individual circumstances.

10 Likes

Are there industrial customers here? So can this problem spread to assembly lines stopping somewhere? Some products have surprisingly big quantities of silver these days.

That price too low for too long is reverse inflation problem… same way it can be years like that until it suddenly finally explodes like now.

To me this looks gold is doing fine, plenty of it sitting in vaults, many goldmines booming now… but ironically very few daily items need gold… but copper, and maybe silver are those daily drivers. Unobtainium looks to be word of the day.

4 Likes

I asked Grok to clarify the Silver Academy article “India Unleashes Silver as Banking Collateral with 10-to-1 Gold-Silver Ratio—Declares Silver as Global Monetary Metal”

Me:

So basically, the banks now accept silver as collateral on loans, at a 10:1 ratio to gold - similar to the gold-to-silver ratio that metal prices maintained at certain points in history?

Grok:

Yes, exactly — you’ve summarized it well.

The RBI is now allowing banks to accept silver as collateral for loans, on par with gold, but with a fixed 10:1 valuation ratio. That means:

  • 1 unit of gold collateral value = 10 units of silver collateral value
    (in the bank’s lending calculation)

This 10:1 ratio is regulatory, not market-based. It’s not reflecting current spot prices (which are around 80:1 or higher). Instead, it’s a deliberate policy choice that:

  1. Recognizes silver’s monetary role — echoing historical periods (like the U.S. Coinage Act of 1792) when silver and gold were legally valued at 15:1 or 16:1.
  2. Adjusts for risk — silver is more volatile and less liquid than gold, so the 10:1 acts as a haircut to protect banks.
  3. Encourages lending against silver — especially for rural and small borrowers who hold more silver than gold.

Simple Example:

Asset Market Value Effective Collateral Value (per RBI)
100g gold ₹7,50,000 ₹7,50,000
1,000g silver ₹90,000 ₹9,000 (treated as 100g gold)

So yes — practically, it’s like the bank is saying:

“We’ll treat your silver as if it were gold — but you need 10x the amount.”

It’s a historic step: the first time a major central bank has formally reintroduced silver into modern collateral frameworks with a fixed ratio to gold. Not based on today’s prices, but on monetary tradition and risk management — a quiet but significant nod to silver’s past as money.

9 Likes

Toward the end of the show, Chris mentions that his health insurance costs may be going way up in the near future. One viable alternative may be Crowd Health, which sounds like a true way to pool risk. (coupon code: darkhorse)

Full disclosure, I haven’t tried this product, but my plan is to switch to them should I ever lose my software engineering gig. (Tech is good but volatile…) I heard about them through the Darkhorse Podcast, which is also what introduced me to Chris when he was interviewed by Brett Weinstein.

7 Likes

At the risk of turning Peak Prosperity into a sports site, I need to say that the last time Georgia Tech went 7-0 to start a season was NOT 1966, it was 1990 when they went 11-0 and were co-national champions.

GO JACKETS! STING 'EM!

5 Likes

Chris, this is why they want us all to die via chronic disease or to stop having babies. THEN we can salvage the existing infrastructure we no longer need and that will supply the raw materials we need for the future.

1 Like

This is a fairly concerning chart:

https://x.com/Amdalleq/status/1211851606641135617

At least in the sense of saying, “As long as it’s never different, then we’re at the top of a long-term cycle.”

For this next chart, left axis alert! But if you can mentally adjust for the axis, this is a pretty big change in behavior. I’m not sure yet what it means, but I have some guesses:

https://x.com/FedGuy12/status/1981767000318767354

This is an AWESOME chart:
https://x.com/Sorenthek/status/1981409962015281345

And this is vital context. Wonky, but vital:
https://x.com/DarioCpx/status/1981565548560593365

Finally, this too tells a very big tale:

4 Likes

I wonder if it would be more instructive to see the last chart as treasuries vs gold in ounces/kg. If they are pricing gold in dollars, the chart could still have the same appearance, even just by inaction on the part of the bank.

2 Likes

Thanks for sharing - I’m going to check this out. I’ve been using health shares for quite a while now (currently Zion Health), but this looks interesting.

4 Likes

Whoops, there goes another one:

https://x.com/kshaughnessy2/status/1982053072240091537

4 Likes

Either gold has to fall a lot or silver has to rise a lot…at least in dollar terms:

https://x.com/TaviCosta/status/1982201016574771587

10 Likes

I’ll take, silver rises a lot, for $200, please!

5 Likes

Mr Slammy is in the house.
Which is Gold and which is Silver?
.


.

.

1 Like

Heavy squinting… ~ 5am and 7am slams this time. I expected clockwork 4am.

Nice, I’d be interested to hear how it goes. I can picture risk pools like Crowd Health exploding in popularity as health insurance premiums increase and people lose their jobs in economic downturns.