So It's Back To First Principles (Part 1)

Here is another update to some investigation tools, and my latest timeline analysis. The timeline analysis is fairly comprehensive, so it’s 150 slides long. Unfortunately, I had to reduce the image resolution to get the file size small enough to post here. You can get the higher resolution version on the shared File Browser.

I guarantee you’ll learn a few things you didn’t know before, and you’ll have a clear understanding of where the ESU operators were and when, and what they were doing after the shooting

Invesigative Tools

Research Tools (Rev 19).pdf (3.8 MB)

Recognition Tools (Rev 27).pdf (3.9 MB)

Timeline Analysis (*)

Timeline Analysis - ESU Post-Shooting (Rev 2 Low Res).pdf (7.9 MB)

(*) By accessing this document you agree to the Terms of Use contained within.

2 Likes

Butler County first responders to lead Trump’s Inauguration Day parade – Butler Eagle

After being thrust into the national eye following an attempted assassination of President-elect Donald Trump at the Butler Farm Show grounds on July 13, Butler County first responders will headline his second inauguration.

Nearly 100 first responders from 19 different agencies across the county will be the first group to march in Monday’s Inauguration Day parade behind the U.S. Army Band.

The contingent, consisting of first responders, firefighters and law enforcement personnel, will be led by members of the Pennsylvania State Police Ceremonial Unit.

Many of those who will be in attendance did not hesitate to risk their own lives as shots rang out. They were quick to treat the victims of the tragedy, which included Buffalo Township firefighter Corey Comperatore, who was killed while protecting his family from gunfire.

Corey Comperatore’s widow, Helen Comperatore, hailed the response from emergency personnel as they rushed over to assist her family.

“They were amazing that day,” she said. “What they were thrown into, and just how they reacted, was just unbelievable. My heart goes out to them as well. They were so compassionate and wonderful with my family.”

She also noted that their sacrifices are more than worthy of being lifted up during what will be a historic event for the country.

“They had a lot on their hearts too,” she added. “We met with a lot of them after everything calmed down. What they went through emotionally was very, very hard. I’m just so grateful that they get this chance to go and show themselves. I’m so proud of Butler County. My husband would have been very proud of how they were.”

Multiple teams of first responders were already in action long before the campaign rally spiraled into chaos, as they treated more than 250 patients for mostly heat-related ailments.

“I’m immensely proud of our responders and am humbly part of them,” said Butler County 911 Coordinator Robert McLafferty. “The actions that they took that day were just truly awe-inspiring. Without concern for their own safety, they went right in to take care of the folks who needed immediate care.”

Kevin Hulbert, who is associated with an organization called “The Patriot Flag,” contacted Trump’s inaugural committee with the idea of sending Butler’s first responders to the inauguration before reaching out to multiple county officials, including Commissioners Leslie Osche and Kim Geyer, and Sheriff Mike Slupe.

Eventually, that message reached McLafferty, who worked with Hulbert and Butler Memorial Hospital’s Jenna Enscoe to acquire security clearances for all attendees and devise a comprehensive travel plan.

In addition to honoring the first responders for their efforts, Monday’s inauguration parade will provide another opportunity to honor Corey Comperatore for his bravery. Representatives from the Buffalo Township Volunteer Department will lead the procession while carrying his fire helmet and jacket.

“We are forever changed by the devastating loss of our fellow first responder Corey Comperatore,” the trio of Hulbert, McLafferty and Enscoe wrote in a statement to President-elect Trump’s inaugural committee. “We remember past fire chief Comperatore today and forever, as we honor others, including President Trump, David Dutch and James Copenhaver, who survived this murderous attack.

“We hope all Americans will pause today to remember the bravery and sacrifice of their own first responders and police, the expertise of their 911 dispatchers, and the skill of their local hospital emergency and medical staff and emergency management agencies.”

Thank you, both for the updates again to the tools, but also for the Timeline Analysis! This is massive! I went straight for the hires version in the fileshare, making my way through it, this is fantastic! Really nice work, Vegas!

3 Likes

You’re welcome! I hope it provides a good resource for understanding the progression of response activities. (I was watching Trump’s victory rally while proofreading it. Needless to say I missed a lot and will need to go over it again.)

I am looking forward to seeing the responders in the inaugural parade today. It will be fun seeing how many responders we recognize.

2 Likes

I watched some parts of that this morning before they started covering inaugural stuff, and that is quite a lot to proof read, I can absolutely understand missing some things. No worries! If you’d like as I continue to go through it, i can try to highlight any I come across to try to help you pinpoint revisions.

And indeed, I’m quite excited to see who all shows up from Butler, given our extensive recognition efforts I’m sure we’ll catch quite a few cameos!

1 Like

Thanks for the offer of pointing out the errors I missed, but I’ve already started a revision with corrections Just enjoy the content. If you find anything factual you think I got wrong, feel free to point it out, though.

1 Like

By the way. Mr Trump took a great speach.

3 Likes

That’s fine, it’ll probably make it easier to digest, as it is quite packed with information! I’m really only about a 5th of the way through it so far and still keep coming across details I hadn’t noticed before, you’ve done a truly fantastic job of cataloging and explaining things!

//

As far as the parade, I actually didn’t really catch many that I recognized immediately, definitely Rico Elmore, and I don’t know if it has to do with the setting indoors vs outdoors, but I will be looking back through the footage to see if anyone else of note stands out.

//


“Could you imagine Biden doing this? I don’t think so!” :rofl:

3 Likes

I thonk the only one I recognized during their brief appearance was Sgt. Lenz. The camera kept bouncing around making it difficult.

Thanks again for the compiments on my analysis. I can’t believe how many typos and other errors I’m finding today. I’m up to page 80, and keep finding more. I even had a few names wrong that were related to our last minute discovery of Mike Crawford, and my second guessing of Huminsky. Ugh!

2 Likes

I did notice that, and understood exactly how that’s what we must have been talking about when you were last working on that section, or at least going through it for revision purposes. No worries!
I’ll just chalk it up to your AI programming! [/sarc] :smiling_imp:

2 Likes

To err is human. Usually I cannot see my mistakes immediately, when my brain remembers (word by word) what I wanted to write. It is a good strategy to read it back some later.

By the way, today is today, and I hope FBI starts a new investigation right now.

“U.S. government was unable to protect its own borders, while they spent countless resources to defend other countries” Mr. Trump said. (And they also failed, I would add. (Well, I changed the order of his words to point out my conclusion.))

May I ask, Iran why didn’t attack Russia or China? Perhaps bc they have a strong leadership, imho.

2 Likes

Aha! I think I’ve got it! After finding Engine 12 for Connoquenessing Volunteer Fire Company nearby in the same video, and browsing their facebook:


Facebook

2 Likes

Bingo! Good work. I’ll add them to the tools. It’s interesting that all 4 vehicles in the photo you found were at the rally. Is that their whole fleet?

1 Like

Not quite their whole fleet, it appears they also have a Tanker, and perhaps a few other extraneous vehicles, but seemingly most(if not all) of their fleet was present:




2 Likes

I would have thought they would leave at least one fire truck back in their community.

I have uploaded Rev. 2 of my ESU timeline analysis to the File Browser. It has corrections, but no real substantive changes. Here is the low resolution version.

Timeline Analysis - ESU Post-Shooting (Rev 2 Low Res).pdf (7.9 MB) (*)

(*) By accessing this document, you agree to the Terms of Use contained within.

2 Likes

I got this from a reference made on a recent Tucker Carlson interview. Crooks was a fairly smart guy. A lot of people say “ooh, he was super smart” but the 1530 on his SAT is 98% percentile, not 99%, so he didn’t make National Merit Finalist. Also, there’s been a LOT of grade inflation over the last forty years, so those mostly A’s and B’s are not very impressive in my mind.

He got kind of stressed out getting a B in calc 3 and a C in diff EQ’s the fall of 2023, but that was a pretty ambitious course load for a Freshman!

3 Likes

I concur, there is no generic way to solve them. Each type needs another strategy.

2 Likes

Another update to these investigation tools.

Research Tools (Rev 20).pdf (3.8 MB)

Filled in more of the Interview Transcript tables.

Recognition Tools (Rev 28).pdf (4.4 MB)

  1. Changed Tactical Vehicles (3) slide to Other Response Vehicles, and added images of more vehicles to it.
  2. Added Command & Control Staff (2) slide listing those posted in the BuC Command Center.
  3. Added Tactical Response Members slide listing all operators on each team.
  4. Reorganized slightly and filled in more of the USSS Operations slides.

My favorite update was puting a face to the name of Joshua Box, USSS CAT Operator. Finally!

5 Likes

I’m going to do a crummy summary of what I found interesting on D. King’s testimony: https://taskforce.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/july13taskforce.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/CS-Sgt-Tech.pdf

I just summarized at first because most of the document doesn’t allow for copy and paste. After a while I went to split screen so I could transcribe from my browser to excel without flipping back and forth, so everything that is here I typed out:

Page 10
He has been with the secret service almost 24 years.
He initially states he has not had a change in duties since July 13. (He’s lying).

Page 11
He says he was initially on leave for 5 days, and he has been on desk duty since then (as of Nov 21 - 4+ months!). (So he did SOMETHING really wrong, maybe that 10 second lag after shot 8 stretched the plausible deniability too far?).

He says he has not been interviewed regarding mission assurance or as part of any other investigation, and does not know of any pending investigation.

Page 31
Rep. Clay Higgins: So it was a black hills loaded 300 Win Mag with a Hornady 210 grain projectile or bullet. And was that a hollow point bullet? What was the configuration of the bullet?
D. King: It’s a hollow point.

Page 32
Rep Higgins: Okay. And it was a copper jacket lead core?
King: Yes, Sir

(Let’s talk amongst ourselves about this, shall we?) Rep Higgins asks D. King what he thinks a hollow point from a win mag does to a body, and D. King says he doesn’t know, but imagines it would frag.

King: The first time I went up on the roof, is when I took my post for July 13.

2 Likes

P. 36
Rep. Higgins:

It’s said that [redacted] explained Crooks’ position was quote/unquote, at the peak line of a slightly pitched roof and that your sight picture was of his head and the tops of his shoulders is when you actually saw Crooks and recognized him as a threat.
So this is important. At the ridge line versus where you turned him off was about 4 or 5 feet different. So something happened between the time he fired his eight rounds and Butler County ESU tactical officer [Zaliponi] fired the ninth round, which was almost simultaneous with the eighth round fired by Mr. Crooks. Something happened and he moved back from the ridge line 4 or 5 feet. That’s what my investigation reveals.

Page 37
King: Yes sir.

King: So basically, what I observed, after the shot was fired I got into my rifle, looked through the scope. And I noticed that he was – he wasn’t a high – he wasn’t – it wasn’t like a high silhouette off the peak. He was just – it was a low profile on the peak where I could basically just make out, like I said, the tops of his shoulders and his head. And I could see his weapon.

2 Likes

I have less time recently to read the transcripts. Any reference how they abandoned that AGR rooftop? I haven’t seen yet, only Collins mentioned he was about to climb down when suit agent arrived.

2 Likes