Stop Feeding Your Children to the Beast

Originally published at: https://peakprosperity.com/stop-feeding-your-children-to-the-beast/

This year’s Peak Prosperity Annual Summit happened just one day after Charlie Kirk’s assassination. Many showed up with feelings of shock and helplessness. The shock was not just that Charlie had been murdered, but also how people on the left were reacting to it. Twitter feeds were clogged with grotesque posts of people joyously celebrating the murder of a husband and father who had done nothing more than exercise his supposedly inalienable freedom of speech. It was a gut-wrenching, sobering realization of just how far gone many on America’s political left had become. This led to the second feeling: helplessness. The gap between the left and right – which many had hoped could be repaired – had been suddenly laid bare as irreconcilable. If the left had progressed to the point of celebrating murder, how could we possibly bridge the divide and fix American culture? In the battleground for moral identity, there is simply too big a gap between “us” (defend to the death your right to speech) and “them” (murder you for your speech).

As shock and helplessness gave way to conversation and analysis, a striking realization came. Many of those disturbing public displays of celebration seemed to be coming from government employees, nurses, and teachers. One similarity between these professions is their service to the common good, a commitment to collective welfare over individual profit. Another is that these are credentialed, state-regulated professions built on standardized academic pipelines, sharing an “institutional DNA” often very distinct from private-sector professions. If that’s the case, what could any one of us do to effectively combat the institutionalized, collectivist thinking that inevitably leads to prioritizing the “greater good” over the sovereignty of the individual?

What can you do? More than you think – and it starts with refusing to institutionalize your children, refusing to feed the beast the one thing it cannot survive without: your children.

By “your children,” I also mean your grandchildren, your nieces and nephews, the kids next door, or any young lives you can touch. This revolution needs every single one of us.

The Enemy in Plain Sight

Perhaps Charlie Kirk understood all too well something most Americans don’t yet fully appreciate: that the enemy has been hiding in plain sight – our educational institutions.

Charlie Kirk focused his attention on our colleges and universities, but the foundation is laid far earlier in our public schools. The K-12 years are the most formative, during which children are slowly forged into “functional” adults. The question then becomes, “Whose definition of ‘functional’ is being used?” It certainly isn’t the parents’. As soon as a parent surrenders their child to the school system, they have delegated most of their child-rearing responsibilities to that system. Since the public school system is run by the government, this means the raising of children has been effectively outsourced to the government. Therefore, they will become “functional” based on the government’s definition of the word.

If you’re the conspiratorial type, you might think the government’s primary definition of “functional” is an obedient and/or productive worker. If you’re the cynical type, you might think they’ve never actually defined “functional,” and therefore they produce dysfunctional adults. And, if you’re the pessimistic type, you might have already figured out they’re simply producing dysfunctional, obedient adults.

Of course, some students do great! This, of course, is the nature of bell curves. A small percentage of kids succeed, and the rest do not. That said, I would argue these kids do well despite the system, not because of the system.

Stop Letting the Government Raise Your Children

Still feeling helpless? Let’s fix that.

Charles Franklin Kettering once said, “A problem well-defined is a problem half-solved.” If we can agree that public schools are a problem, then you’re halfway to solving it. The first half of the solution is easy. Stated bluntly because of its importance: get your children out of the school system. It’s that simple. The first half of the solution is the “what,” and the second half of the solution is the “how.” This is the greater challenge, but it’s not as hard as you think. For now, pause right here and accept what needs to be done, so that you can start focusing on how.

You Win the Moment You Walk Away

What you will do is gain a huge increase in parenting time. Between the ages of 5 and 18, children will spend about 19,200 hours away from home based on average bell-to-bell and transportation times across 180 days per year. Out of 57,000 remaining waking hours during the K-12 years, that represents a minimum 34% increase in parenting time, assuming 100% of those hours are actually available to the parents. In reality, the percentage increase is significantly higher. Regardless, this has many implications:

  • More time together: Families that spend more time together end up having better relationships with each other.
  • No more one-size-fits-all: Multiple alternative options become available, allowing the child to be paired with the option that makes the most sense for them.
  • Proper pacing: Children are able to go at the right pace for each subject, meaning they’re neither held back nor left behind.
  • Interest-led: Parents can tailor content to the individual interests of the child, allowing for a high level of educational engagement.
  • No homework: When not in a classroom setting, children learn concepts faster and typically do not need homework.
  • Less wasted time: Less time lost to bus rides, hallway time, settling down the class, and giving out homework means more productive use of time.
  • More control: The parent can choose what to include and exclude from their child’s education. Don’t want gender studies? No problem.
  • Better socialization: Homeschool children are typically better socialized because they routinely interact with many walks of life (young people, old people, more mature, less mature, etc.). When in real life are you only surrounded by people your own age and maturity level?
  • Less bullying: An increasingly big reason people homeschool is to avoid bullying and other bad influences that come with public schools

How to Pull Your Kids Out (It’s Easier Than You Think)

How you will do it is the tougher nut to crack, but it’s surprisingly not as hard as you might think. Once you decide you must remove your child from the school system, your mindset switches from “Why can’t I do this?” to “How do I do this?” Now, the second half of the solution comes more easily.

First, start by understanding your state or country’s homeschool laws. If in the U.S., visit the Homeschool Legal Defense Association (HSLDA) and look up your state. Their information on individual state requirements is free and always up to date. Also, consider joining once you get going. The HSLDA is to homeschoolers what the NRA is to gun owners. If you ever run into trouble with your local school district, their legal team will swoop in to the rescue.

Second, find local homeschoolers in your area. They are almost everywhere. Facebook is a great place to start, but you may also find regional organizations by searching the web. Connecting with a homeschooler will give you a person who can serve as local encouragement. More importantly, they will help you begin developing your social networks, which will be important for learning outside the home. Homeschoolers will often do their core learning at home but then participate in group activities (field trips, outings, learning groups, etc.).

Third, determine if there are any public resources available that you would like to use. Notwithstanding all the talk of how corrupt “the system” is, there are some state-level programs that can be quite empowering. Many states now have educational savings accounts (or something by a similar name) that make state funds available with minimal strings attached. For example, an attached string might be a required annual standardized assessment. The available programs, benefits, and obligations will vary by state.

Fourth, find basic core materials to get you started. This is going to vary wildly from family to family and is typically the most overwhelming part. There are so many options that it can feel impossible to sift, sort, and select what works for you and your child. Don’t let this stop you! You may spend days/weeks/months researching options until your hair is on fire, then finally pick something only to find out it doesn’t work for you. Don’t despair – there are plenty of buy/swap/sell groups for this sort of turnover. It may take some trial and error at first, but this is a good thing because it means you’re tailoring the program to exactly what your child needs. This would not happen in a public school. Eventually, you will hit your stride.

Start with the basics, especially when they’re young. For the young kids in my household (ages 5-8), we use Logic of English for literacy and Beast Academy for math. For the older kids (10+) we use Beast Academy and Art of Problem-Solving for math, Oak Meadow for English, history, and science, Rosetta Stone for foreign language, and Institute of Excellence in Writing for… well, writing. That said, don’t take these as prescriptive – it’s just to get the gears turning. Other families swear by Acellus Academy, local co-ops, Outschool, road-schooling, or game-schooling. Be open and adaptable, but keep it simple when you start, building and modifying as you gain experience.

Fifth, and most importantly, just do it. Don’t let perfect become the enemy of good. Even homeschoolers who do the bare minimum will often find their kids test out better than the public school average. Here are some common excuses to get out of the way:

  • I won’t have time. It doesn’t take nearly as much time as you think. Piece it into your schedule wherever it makes sense for you. Make time as needed – it’s important.
  • What about sports? Children can usually join sports teams at public schools even if not attending. You can also join private gyms. If you use educational savings accounts, those will typically pay for sports.
  • I can’t teach [insert subject here]. If you can read, write, and do basic math, you can teach a young child. As older students, they will typically transition to independent learning, and you can also find programs that do the “teaching” for you. Regardless, nearly all good homeschool resources provide guidebooks for the parent. One-on-one with a parent is nearly always better than 15-on-one with a public school teacher.
  • What about high school? Most people have the parental commitment level backwards. It’s the youngest kids who require the most time. Older kids are far more capable of being self-driven and independent learners. Your job is to figure out their interests and help align them with the best tool for how they like to learn.
  • I want them to go to college. Good! This isn’t a problem and, in fact, many homeschoolers discover they are at a competitive advantage over public school students.
  • I can’t afford it. It’s entirely possible to homeschool on a shoestring budget. It just means you may have to do extra work (i.e., print from PDFs instead of ordering books already printed, etc.). As mentioned, look into educational savings accounts, which can help tremendously.

Reclaim Child-Rearing, and Reclaim Our Culture

Here is the call to action: it’s time to reclaim the child-rearing of our future generations. If you’re a parent, take back and embrace your most sacred duty. Do not relinquish this to the government. If you’re a grandparent, aunt, uncle, etc., figure out how you can help enable homeschooling for your family.

You are not helpless. You may not be able to control what they do, but you can still control what you do. Make the decision today.

Many Americans view our government as a modern-day hydra, hopeless to defeat it because every chopped head grows two more. The belly of the beast is the public education system, and while it still feeds on the youth of our nation, the system will continue to destroy our life, liberty, and happiness until there are no more youth left to feed it. You are not helpless to stop it, and you are not alone. In 1999, only 1.7% of American students were homeschooled. In 2019, it moved to 3.0%. By 2024, it was 6.73%. That sounds a lot like an exponential curve. Join the revolution, save the children, and save our future.

12 Likes

Beast Academy for math is amazing! My son re-entered the school system begging to play high school football and baseball and is a freshman taking AP PreCal now. Sets you up for major success. Also love Story of the World. Their hours of audio history were a staple for our car rides for years and taught the kids and I so much history in a cool away. Highly recommend that even to folks not homeschooling.

Dang this post makes me feel guilty for letting them have my kids again- I’m watching it closely and ready to pull at any moment.

Love the idea you don’t have to be the parent to be the homeschool teacher! Amen!!! Also if you can find a good co-op do it, or work it out with a friend. My neighbor was a college Engineering professor one year she taught her son and mine math while I did English with her daughter.

8 Likes

There are so many great supports for homeschoolers. Many dedicated educators create fantastic curriculums. You don’t have to do it from scratch and it does not have to look like public school.

I found that my kids always wanted that bit of downtime attention at night before bed. I gave them their reading lesson then read part of a story or we used puppets and stuffed animals to create our own sit-coms. This was interesting in that it gave me insight on their concerns and views and interests.

There was a time when I worked out of the home a few hours a week in a general contractors home office and took the kids with me a couple days a week. They had an open attic with a spiral stair case full of toys and games, my office was in a room with a large play kitchen setup in it and they had the entire collection of Disney DVDs, a jacuzzi and a waterfall in the back yard and two small dogs and a collection of outfits for them. The grandkids of my employers were there some of the time. I did bookkeeping, payroll, and interfaced with big box stores regarding home renovation projects.

Perhaps as important as what goes on in the public schools is what takes place online, TV, and over the airwaves.

And then there is college. :astonished_face:

4 Likes

I’m not even a Christian, but I am planning on sending my son to a Christian school - specifically for many of the reasons listed above. I appreciate many of the moral teachings of Christianity even if I am not a believer in the the theology. I am not sure I can manage the time commitment of homeschooling, but I would certainly find a way to make it work before I would send him to public school. And as you point out, the younger kids take the most time commitment. I may start homeschooling once he gets past the first few years and is able to read his own textbooks. He is only two right now, so I have some time to figure it out.

6 Likes

Like you, I was so excited to homeschool my kids that I was already thinking about it when they were that age. One of the best pieces of advice I was given on “how to homeschool kids that are 2” was simply, “Don’t do for a child that which he can do for himself.” So much of education is simply developing good habits, which in turn leads to discipline.

I know people who have turned to local Christian private schools – even though they’re not religious – simply to avoid the woke ideologies promoted to some degree in seemingly every public school. This is definitely a viable path, and far more preferable to public school. The kids I know who have gone this route seem to be much more mature and better educated. That said, I’m of course biased towards home-based education, which I feel is ultimately more effective in developing truly independent learners (and giving you more time with them).

3 Likes

I have thought about and discussed with my wife the idea of home schooling.
We’re Dutch and live in Spain and as such we have other considerations.

First is that the state of the school system here is not as bad as it seems in the US when it comes to promoting certain ideologies.
Second is the language, our kids (5&9) now speak better Spanish then myself and my wife.

But mainly I’m looking at the time commitment. I can’t see how to squeeze in the time to educate them.

For me this actually reinforces the idea that the system is designed for two incomes now and even then not easy to make a generous living.
Many of the options around the school, such as extra curricular activities or after school day care are tailored to that. Here in Spain most of those are also free or very cheap.

The end result of all that is that a. It will take a lot more of my time, meaning lower income. b. It will cost more.

So, yes, I feel it’s important, but I think for many families it doesn’t strike me as feasible.

Perhaps there are people here that are in, or were in, similar situations, how did you manage it?

3 Likes

Our local school district will only allow homeschools to take part in sports if they are enrolled in public school at least 50%. Music, however, they could take as a stand-alone elective.

Public school kids were often jealous of our kids. Parents often assumed that since we choose to homeschool, that meant that we thought they were bad parents for not homeschooling. (Similar to my in-laws who thought that since we choose to parent differently than they did, that we were condemning their parenting style.) Not every family is meant to homeschool. There are other alternatives, like parochial schools, that are better than public school. And even if you must use the public school, stay engaged with what your child is being taught! So many parents just hand their kids over and never check in to see what is going on in the classroom. There is so much you can do to supplement what is being taught in school. No educator knows your child better than you do! If our kids showed interest in something, we tried to encourage that interest. You don’t have to homeschool to do that.

2 Likes

I wonder if these organizations from The Netherlands might help you find others in Spain to share homeschooling responsibilities with?

Also, there are groups in Spain:

Homeschool World: Spain Homeschool Organizations and Support Groups

The time commitment to homeschool is different then the time kids are spending in traditional schools. There is a LOT of time wasted in public school,and very little real learning. Most homeschoolers find they can get the same of more work done in a fraction of the time. I know very few homeschooler who spend a formal 7 hours a day on lessons (if they are doing this they are almost always new to homeschooling,lol) most homeschool families spend 1-2 hours on formal lessons (less when younger,more when older) and the rest of the time is for child play, experimentation and exploration or extra curriculars. Time doing nothing is just as valuable in my mind as time spent on formal lessons for glettung the brain grow and develop and that is a huge piece they are missing in public schools.

8 Likes

In the USA, it’s often the case that by time a family spends the money needed to keep the second patent working full time, such as day care costs for before and after school care they could be as well off with part time work that did not require child care. The costs of keeping two newer cars instead of one new and one older, fuel and increased insurance, for a second work commute, day care, eating out more, clothing and dry cleaning expenses, lunches away from home and on and on decrease the net gains. Sometimes the math of giving the children their mother means a couple of lifestyle changes is all that is required. For some getting rid of TV service and driving more modest automobiles, is enough to cover what mom nets after expenses.

After finishing our homeschooling day in less than two hours on average, I was often left wondering what actually takes the other several hours a day at school.

From a very early age my kids had a 15-20 minute chore to do each day in addition to making their own bed and tidying up their room. Over the course of a week this added up to several hours of house work. That was an offset for my time. The were simple jobs like wiping the baseboards and window sills in two rooms, or washing two windows, or collecting cobwebs from the ceilings with a dust mop and dusting the top of door frames. Simple quick easy, they got training on then a few rounds so it was ojt.

TV and Internet are also key issues to consider regardless of where they go to school.

5 Likes

This is an important point. One of the things often discussed at Peak Prosperity is the corrupt money system. Over the past century, the purchasing power of our currency has been devalued to the point where two or more incomes are required just to make ends meet. This certainly adds to the challenge of raising healthy families and educating children (i.e. the feedback loop of dependence on the system).

As such…

There are many ways to address this concern. Firstly, it doesn’t take nearly as long as most people think. I spend only a few hours per week (not day) “teaching” my fifth-grader. Most of that time is spent prepping her material for the week, reviewing her assignments, and discussing items with her that she may not fully understand. Otherwise, her time is spent learning (not being taught to) on her own.

Looking across several independent and online homeschool programs, a common theme I see is that most require 2-4 hours per day. The low-end would be most independent learners and the high-end would be your struggling students. Regardless, this is compared to 6 hours in public school (not included bus rides and homework). Of note, this is the student’s time, not yours.

As for your time, the tools you select have a big impact on the commitment involved. Some involve lots of parental time; others, very little. For example, you can spend the time to create your own curriculum, piece together all the components, print off materials, and teach it to your kids. Or, you could purchase curricula already put together that’s designed to be completed more independently. Or, you can use video-based programs or even full-fledged online programs that come with a human teacher. An example of a popular program in the U.S. is Acellus Academy. When it comes to these programs, and even many self-directed programs, your time commitment becomes similar to what it would be if you were helping your student with their public school’s homework.

The other thing to keep in mind is that you have complete flexibility over schedule. Work during the day? Conduct “school time” during the evening. You can also divvy up responsibilities between parents. In my case, I focus on the academics and my partner focuses on enrichment activities.

This makes me think of Dave Fairtex’s “easy / hard” framework. They will always make it “easy” for you to stay in their system and play by their rules. The “harder” path is to do something different. That said, many of the obstacles are more misconception than actual roadblocks. I don’t know much about Spain’s system, but in the U.S. it just takes a little determination and creativity. Easy is not always best (gold ETFs anyone?).

2 Likes

Excellent point. This cuts right to the heart of the problem that is “trust the experts.” I liken it to blindly taking an mRNA vaccine. Most people have been raised to believe the “experts” are always right and always have our best interests at heart. The truth is far more complicated, hence why authority should always be questioned and why we should never defer to complacency.

4 Likes

I absolutely failed the stay in your seat test when it came to flash cards and spelling lists. I just could not, however my husband was made for it. He enjoyed it and it gave him a spot in the kids’ homeschooling process. He drilled times tables, states and capitols, and nations and capitols and finding counties on the map, spelling word lists, and other memorization tasks. This sort of stuff was done on days I went to work without the kids.

2 Likes

Yes, when you factor in the cost of child care and all the additional costs of working full time (transport, lunches/coffees out, etc.) Very often it makes sense to just stay home. Then what is the value of being able to actually raise your own kid? Priceless.

I was a teacher for a litlle bit. I only lasted one year in a public school and came away with the overwhelming sense that the best thing I could do toelp the world and the kids was be there for my own, and ensure they didn’t end up like my students.

When I was teaching it was just almost impossible to do anything real or meaningful with the class. There was so little real learning time, most of the day was spend on procedures just trying to get them to a place where i could teach them something. Honestly I think the only meaningful thing I did all year was read them the book The Glass Castle (these were eighth graders, I censored it somewhat in class and told them and their parents they had to read it themselves to get the uncensored version). These kids could case less about fiction, but they really identified with the main character in that book and were constantly shouting out things like “my mom did that too!” And other borderline CPS report revelations. But they were intereated enough that we had some good debated and they actually wrote some really excellent essays by the end of the year about which parent in the book was worse, the mother or the father.

But I think that is literally the only meaningful learning experience they had all year long, and honestly I felt lucky to even have achieved that.

4 Likes

I was home schooled from grades 2-10 back in the 70’s-80’s. My folks actually immigrated from the US to Canada to home school because it wasn’t legal in the US at that time. They were committed. But they were also in a fight to survive the isolated, off-grid, working-class-wage supported homesteading life they chose and our schooling was far from perfect.

We had to leave all our young friends behind, learn animal care and many other homesteading skills including living off-grid, adapting to lots of physical labor, dealing with deep snow and long winters, and coping with parents who were sometimes exhausted and utterly without patience. With all that going on, time for lessons was limited and often sporadic.

The point I want to make is that it worked anyway. Mom was confident and meticulous with English skills. She not only taught us everything language-related but also read to us by the hour in the evenings (no TV, no internet). We all inherited the joy of reading and writing. Dad was a great methodical thinker and could explain math and science so that each level made sense before the next was introduced. Still, we would sometimes go for months with barely any formal lessons but, with those basic skills, we learned constantly anyway, following our own interests. We used books and libraries. Can you imagine!

When we each decided to go to public school (Mom and Dad left that choice to us after age 14 or so), there was testing to see what grade we belonged in. We were ahead of our age groups across the board. I waited until grades 11-12, and got almost straight A’s.

So even short, infrequent lessons, (but skilled, methodical and personalized) trumped school. It also left us with what they wanted for us: an ingrained ability to think for ourselves, and nervous systems profoundly attuned to nature, not to the school system. Both are invaluable to me, set the tone for my entire life and are my foundation still 50 years later.

I don’t have children and don’t know how it would be, in this age of internet, to home school. Some friends are doing it, successfully so far. There is lots of homesteading and real-life, hands-on learning going on. But if a child were in my care, I would home school. What my parents gave us when they took that responsibility was a rare and precious form of wealth I would not trade for any other.

Susan

11 Likes

Wow a homeschooling modern pioneer.

We did a lot of that homestead type learning but it was not survival make a living level effort. I hope not gave the kids some insight on where and how food comes to them and appreciation for the level of work involved. When you harvest a laundry basket of spinache and it wilts down into what fits in a can at the store you appreciate what’s on that can a whole lot more.

It’s so much easier these days. My favorite hack was a cd based curriculum called Teaching Textbooks. The lesson / problems were presented as sort of like animated writing on a white board with the teachers voice. The kids would work their problems and then look at the solution. If they missed they would be presented the work through of that problem then another similar problem. After a couple tries the lesson would be presented again. If it went past that the came and got me and we watched together and found the misunderstanding.

There is an entire free collection of courses called Khan Academy.

They probably have vegan and gluten free and keto homeschool curriculums these days something for everyone.

3 Likes

Our kids went to a public Waldorf charter school up until high school. But during Covid, they went with online even though that is in direct opposition with Waldorf principals. Our son and two of his friends decided to cram their entire education that year into 2 weeks using Khan Academy. Then for the rest of their school time, they played games while keeping their webcams on so they were counted as attending class. When we had the teacher conference, his teacher explained that our son appeared not to be paying attention, but always knew the answer when called upon. Hmmm, I wonder why?

So yes, if a student is motivated they can learn all the content in a fraction of the time spent in traditional classrooms.

7 Likes

YES! This is a great point. You don’t have to be perfect, heck, you can be far from it, but if you are involved in what your kids are doing they will thrive.

4 Likes

My mom “home-schooled” me at age 4. She was a teacher - her goal was to teach me to love reading. It worked, throughout my childhood I read probably a book a day. I taught myself history, and political science - those were my interests. That, and science fiction. Book example: Rise & Fall of the Third Reich, at age 10. That took longer than a day though.

I went to public school like “normal” - where I did the minimum since it was mostly quite boring.

Outcome: I can teach myself. During the pandemic I’d read all these papers. I wasn’t intimidated since I’ve been doing that kind of thing since age 10.

Thanks Mom!

11 Likes

Public school suck. This is an 8th grade project. And the administrators are agents.